Stuttgart 21: Symbol for the “arrogance of power?”

Spread the love

stuttgart 21The latest of several protests in Stuttgart against the German city’s multi-billion euro renovation scheme has again attracted thousands of people.

It was largely peaceful but late in the evening 27 demonstrators were arrested, accused of blocking a road.

The project “Stuttgart 21” aims to turn the main rail terminus into an underground through-station. It would enable the city to become an international transport hub. Stuttgart would join one of Europe’s major high-speed rail routes, linking Paris, Strasbourg and Munich, and on to Vienna, Bratislava and Budapest.

Talks failed to halt early demolition work to part of the station.

Critics challenge the cost which has soared from the original estimate of around four billion euros. They also want more debate on traffic issues and alternative solutions.

The scheme’s supporters argue it would transform Stuttgart into “the new heart of Europe”, attracting thousand of jobs.

But the row is threatening to fuel more widespread dissent. Some opponents see it as a deal cut by business leaders and politicians and flying in the face of public opinion.

In the words of one local academic, Stuttgart 21 has become a symbol for the “arrogance of power”.

Euro News


Spread the love

Comments

4 responses to “Stuttgart 21: Symbol for the “arrogance of power?””

  1. Actually I dont understand those people protesting against S21. Its not like the project suddenly appeared, it was planned about 20 years ago. There have been elections for four times since then. The party which decided Stuttgart 21 didnt got reelected all these times, in the Landtag as well as the mayor. There have been candidates from other parties promising to stop Stuttgart 21. They didn´t get elected. So either the poeple protesting are not representing the majority or they have been just stupid for a long time.

    Stopping the project now would mean an infringement of crontracts that would still cost 1400000000€ for nothing.

  2. Aww I just noticed a typo. “The party which decided Stuttgart 21 did get reelected all these times, in the Landtag as well as the mayor.

    And I might add that some parties (SPD, Grüne) were in favor of the project for a long time and just recently decided to try to stop it. They even were involved in planning it.

  3. I think most important subject here is that; Why is this project taking place now? Were the economic conditions now same as 20 years ago?
    10 percent lost is not great compare to 1000 % lost. And all this people were gathering there for nothing? Best option maybe a referendum providing that public has got sensitivities to this project and the economic climate is not at it best.

  4. The reelection of the mayor was close and he only won because he promised to hold a referendum. The conditions for this referendum were met pretty soon after his reelection but he did not fulfill his promise.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *