Category: Main Issues

  • iNGILTERE/ Basin Aciklama / Press Release – David Burrowes MP

    iNGILTERE/ Basin Aciklama / Press Release – David Burrowes MP

     

    Joint British Turkish Cypriot NGO Action Group calls for David Burrowes MP to resign as APPG Chairperson for Cyprus

     

    Tuesday, 04th December 2012:  The British Turkish Cypriot Association (BTCA) in conjunction with over 55 British Turkish and British Turkish Cypriot non-government & civil society organizations (INCLUDING TURKISH FORUM)have collectively undersigned this statement as listed in Addendum A.  They are requesting the resignation of David Burrowes as the Chairperson of The British All Party Parliamentary Group for Cyprus (“APPG”).

     

     

    03December 2012

     

    To all members of the Cyprus All Party Parliamentary Group

    House for Commons

    London SW1A 0AA

     

    Dear APPG Member,

     

    RE: DAVID BURROWES

     

    Over 55 British Turkish and British Turkish Cypriot non-government & civil society organizations have collectively undersigned this statement as listed in Addendum A.  We are requesting the resignation of David Burrowes as the Chairperson of The British All Party Parliamentary Group for Cyprus (“APPG”).

     

    Turkish Cypriots living in the UK have lost confidence in David Burrowes as an impartial guardian for the APPG.  We feel that his representation of Cypriot affairs in particular to the House of Commons is far from balanced and contrary to HMG policy.  He has consistently ignored the views of the overwhelming majority of the Turkish Cypriots living in the UK.

     

    As Chairperson of the APPG, and in accordance with the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association principles, his actions should be impartial.  It is incumbent upon him to represent the views of ALL Cypriots.  Openly and without any reasonable justification dismissing British Turkish Cypriot NGO groups simply as “extremists” is incorrect and inappropriate behaviour on the part of Mr Burrowes.  Moreover, his selective refusal to communicate with British Turkish Cypriot NGO groups shows an absolute bias and a closed mindset.

     

    He has failed to exemplify any genuine intentions of using his position to re-connect the two communities and allowing a fair and equitable solution because his door is not open to ALL the Cypriot people and the APPG is not an impartial interlocutor as it is claimed.  David Burrowes has consistently expressed a one-sided attitude in relation to handling British Turkish Cypriot concerns.

     

    By far the worse illustration of his bias is his purposeful omission and demeaning of the destruction of the Turkish Cypriot National Heritage in the south.  More than 25% of the mosques left under the jurisdiction of the “Republic of Cyprus“ have been destroyed.  In contrast, less than 4% of the churches left in the north under Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus’ jurisdiction have been destroyed.  However, Mr. Burrowes’ commentary on this matter leads others to believe that the problem only exists in Northern Cyprus.

     

    David Burrowes conveniently chooses to ignore the facts and unashamedly misleads the House of Commons with false accusations and incorrect statements.  This deliberate and manipulative strategy is unacceptable behaviour from a person who is meant to be impartial.  His polarised views are harming the negotiation process because his actions entrench positions on all sides and he undermines any confidence building measures of the UN and/or the International Community at large.

     

    Turkish and Turkish Cypriots in the UK & Cyprus will no longer tolerate his bias and insulting views.  As the Chairperson of the APPG Mr Burrowes cannot continue to claim to represent both the Greek and Turkish Cypriot communities if he is consistently singing the virtues of one over the other.  This renders his position untenable.

     

    We therefore request that David Burrowes should be requested to resign from his position as Chairperson of the APPG with immediate effect and appoint a person who is unprejudiced, unbiased and non-partisan.

     

    Yours sincerely

     

     

     

     

    Mr. Cetin Ramadan

    Chairman

    British Turkish Cypriot Association

    Joint UK Coordinator

    34-35 D`Arblay Street, London W1F 8EY, United Kingdom

     

      Addendum A

     

    The following UK non-government and civil society organizations have confirmed their support for the statement:

     

    Aksu Türk Birliği
    Anadolu Kultur Merkezi / Anatolian Cultural Centre
    Birmingham Türk Cemiyeti
    British CPTR
    British Turkish Cypriot Association
    Cezire Association
    Doğan Türk Birliği Dayanışma Derneği
    Erenköy Mücahitler Derneği
    Ergazililer Derneği / Ergazililer Association
    Green Tower Turkish Cypriots Elder’s Club
    Güney Londra Türk Yaşlılar Derneği
    Ingiltere Turk Dernekleri Federasyonu / The Federation of Turkish Associations UK

    (representing 16Kıbrıs Türk Cemiyeti BaskanıKıbrıs Türk Kültür DerneğiKıbrıs Türk Ticaret Odası / Cyprus Turkish Chamber of CommerceKuzey Kıbrısla Dayanışma DerneğiNorth London Turkish Islamic Trust / Kuzey Londra Türk İslam VakfıLimasollular DernegiOlıve Tree Educatıon FoundatıonPlan B PlatformPolilıler DerneğiSerdarlı Kıbrıs Türk DerneğiSouthwark Kıbrıs Türk DerneğiSwindon Turkish Cypriot UnionToplumcu Dayanısma DernegiTRNC FreedomTürk BirliğiTurkish Cypriot FoundationTurkish Cypriot Surveyors AssociationTurkish Cypriot TrustTurkish Elders Club / Türk Yaşlılar KulübüTurkish Forum World Turkish Alliance (TFWTA)UBP Londra Dayanısma DernegiUSİAD/TABAVroisha-Yagmuralan AssociationAtaturk Society UK  / Ingiltere Ataturkcu Dusunce DernegiAvrupa Turk BirligiKKTC Magdurlar DernegiAssociation of Turkish Cypriots AbroadTRNC Human Rights Association (UK)The Azerbaijan House (London)

     

      Addendum B

     

    The following TRNC non-government and civil society organizations have confirmed their support for the statement:

     

    ISAD KKTC / TRNC Businessmen Association
    Milli Varolus Konseyi / Council of National Existence
    Ulusal Halk Hareketi  / The National People’s Movement
    Emekli Ast Subaylar / Retired Non-Commissioned Officers
    K.K.T.C Parlamenterler Birligi / TRNC  Parliamentarians  Union
    T.M.T. Mucahiter dernegi / TMT Association of the Mujahideen
    Dunya Kibris Turkleri Vakfi / Worldwide Turkish Cypriot Foundation
    TRNC Human Rights Association
    TRNC Consumers Association
    Trade Union of the Public Service Personnel

     

  • Joint British Turkish Cypriot NGO Action Group calls for David Burrowes MP to resign as APPG Chairperson for Cyprus

    Joint British Turkish Cypriot NGO Action Group calls for David Burrowes MP to resign as APPG Chairperson for Cyprus

    FROM: Cetin Ramadan

    Dear Editor,

     

    Joint British Turkish Cypriot NGO Action Group calls for David Burrowes MP to resign as APPG Chairperson for Cyprus

    Tuesday, 04th December 2012:  The British Turkish Cypriot Association (BTCA) in conjunction with over 55 British Turkish and British Turkish Cypriot non-government & civil society organizations have collectively undersigned this statement as listed in Addendum A.  They are requesting the resignation of David Burrowes as the Chairperson of The British All Party Parliamentary Group for Cyprus (“APPG”).

     

    03 December 2012

     

    To all members of the Cyprus All Party Parliamentary Group

    House for Commons

    London SW1A 0AA

     

    Dear APPG Member,

     

    RE: DAVID BURROWES

     

    Over 55 British Turkish and British Turkish Cypriot non-government & civil society organizations have collectively undersigned this statement as listed in Addendum A.  We are requesting the resignation of David Burrowes as the Chairperson of The British All Party Parliamentary Group for Cyprus (“APPG”).

     

    Turkish Cypriots living in the UK have lost confidence in David Burrowes as an impartial guardian for the APPG.  We feel that his representation of Cypriot affairs in particular to the House of Commons is far from balanced and contrary to HMG policy.  He has consistently ignored the views of the overwhelming majority of the Turkish Cypriots living in the UK.

     

    As Chairperson of the APPG, and in accordance with the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association principles, his actions should be impartial.  It is incumbent upon him to represent the views of ALL Cypriots.  Openly and without any reasonable justification dismissing British Turkish Cypriot NGO groups simply as “extremists” is incorrect and inappropriate behaviour on the part of Mr Burrowes.  Moreover, his selective refusal to communicate with British Turkish Cypriot NGO groups shows an absolute bias and a closed mindset.

     

    He has failed to exemplify any genuine intentions of using his position to re-connect the two communities and allowing a fair and equitable solution because his door is not open to ALL the Cypriot people and the APPG is not an impartial interlocutor as it is claimed.  David Burrowes has consistently expressed a one-sided attitude in relation to handling British Turkish Cypriot concerns.

     

    By far the worse illustration of his bias is his purposeful omission and demeaning of the destruction of the Turkish Cypriot National Heritage in the south.  More than 25% of the mosques left under the jurisdiction of the “Republic of Cyprus“ have been destroyed.  In contrast, less than 4% of the churches left in the north under Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus’ jurisdiction have been destroyed.  However, Mr. Burrowes’ commentary on this matter leads others to believe that the problem only exists in Northern Cyprus.

     

    David Burrowes conveniently chooses to ignore the facts and unashamedly misleads the House of Commons with false accusations and incorrect statements.  This deliberate and manipulative strategy is unacceptable behaviour from a person who is meant to be impartial.  His polarised views are harming the negotiation process because his actions entrench positions on all sides and he undermines any confidence building measures of the UN and/or the International Community at large.

     

    Turkish and Turkish Cypriots in the UK & Cyprus will no longer tolerate his bias and insulting views.  As the Chairperson of the APPG Mr Burrowes cannot continue to claim to represent both the Greek and Turkish Cypriot communities if he is consistently singing the virtues of one over the other.  This renders his position untenable.

     

    We therefore request that David Burrowes should be requested to resign from his position as Chairperson of the APPG with immediate effect and appoint a person who is unprejudiced, unbiased and non-partisan.

     

    Yours sincerely

     

     

    Mr. Cetin Ramadan

    Chairman

    British Turkish Cypriot Association

    Joint UK Coordinator

    34-35 D`Arblay Street, London W1F 8EY, United Kingdom

     

    ENDS/

     

      Addendum A

     

    The following UK non-government and civil society organizations have confirmed their support for the statement:

     

    Aksu Türk Birliği
    Anadolu Kultur Merkezi / Anatolian Cultural Centre
    Birmingham Türk Cemiyeti
    British CPTR
    British Turkish Cypriot Association
    Cezire Association
    Doğan Türk Birliği Dayanışma Derneği
    Erenköy Mücahitler Derneği
    Ergazililer Derneği / Ergazililer Association
    Green Tower Turkish Cypriots Elder’s Club
    Güney Londra Türk Yaşlılar Derneği
    Ingiltere Turk Dernekleri Federasyonu / The Federation of Turkish Associations UK

    (representing 16

    Kıbrıs Türk Cemiyeti Baskanı
    Kıbrıs Türk Kültür Derneği
    Kıbrıs Türk Ticaret Odası / Cyprus Turkish Chamber of Commerce
    Kuzey Kıbrısla Dayanışma Derneği
    North London Turkish Islamic Trust / Kuzey Londra Türk İslam Vakfı
    Limasollular Dernegi
    Olıve Tree Educatıon Foundatıon
    Plan B Platform
    Polilıler Derneği
    Serdarlı Kıbrıs Türk Derneği
    Southwark Kıbrıs Türk Derneği
    Swindon Turkish Cypriot Union
    Toplumcu Dayanısma Dernegi
    TRNC Freedom
    Türk Birliği
    Turkish Cypriot Foundation
    Turkish Cypriot Surveyors Association
    Turkish Cypriot Trust
    Turkish Elders Club / Türk Yaşlılar Kulübü
    Turkish Forum World Turkish Alliance (TFWTA)
    UBP Londra Dayanısma Dernegi
    USİAD/TABA
    Vroisha-Yagmuralan Association
    Ataturk Society UK  / Ingiltere Ataturkcu Dusunce Dernegi
    Avrupa Turk Birligi
    KKTC Magdurlar Dernegi
    Association of Turkish Cypriots Abroad
    TRNC Human Rights Association (UK)
    The Azerbaijan House (London)

     

      Addendum B

     

    The following TRNC non-government and civil society organizations have confirmed their support for the statement:

     

    ISAD KKTC / TRNC Businessmen Association

    Milli Varolus Konseyi / Council of National Existence

    Ulusal Halk Hareketi  / The National People’s Movement 
    Emekli Ast Subaylar / Retired Non-Commissioned Officers
    K.K.T.C Parlamenterler Birligi / TRNC  Parliamentarians  Union
    T.M.T. Mucahiter dernegi / TMT Association of the Mujahideen
    Dunya Kibris Turkleri Vakfi / Worldwide Turkish Cypriot Foundation
    TRNC Human Rights Association
    TRNC Consumers Association
    Trade Union of the Public Service Personnel
  • Book Review: Preposterous Paradoxes of Ambassador Morgenthau: A Factual Story About Politics, Propaganda and Distortions

    Book Review: Preposterous Paradoxes of Ambassador Morgenthau: A Factual Story About Politics, Propaganda and Distortions

    Sukru Server Aya’s new book titled “Preposterous Paradoxes of Ambassador Morgenthau: A Factual Story About Politics, Propaganda and Distortions” is expected to be released in February 1913.


    Here’s a review  by Professor Dr. Ata ATUN:

    The book titled “Ambassador Morgenthau’s Story” written by Mr. Henry Morgenthau Sr. the U.S. Ambassador in Istanbul from 1913 to 1916, on which the Armenian allegations mainly based on, when cross checked day by day with his diary, reveals the fact that it is tailored rather than conveying the real truth on what happened during this era.

    Ambassador Henry Morgenthau, during his 780 days of diplomatic mission in Istanbul, did not even travel ten miles out of the city to any countryside village, except a few on the Bosporus and the Belgrade Forest where he and his friends frequently went horse riding. The only trip he took was by ship to Greece and Egypt in March 1914 and from there to Palestine Holy Lands and cities, ending in Beirut. . .

    From there he boarded his assigned yacht – (gun boat) Scorpion to travel to Mersin, Adana, Rhodes, Smyrna and finally Istanbul in 40 days. It was like a cruise holiday and he never rode on a horse or a car on the soil of Ottoman Empire. He did not travel eastbound, never went further than 10 miles east of Skudari (Üsküdar) and did not visit the eastern regions of Anatolia.

    His book titled “Ambassador Morgenthau’s Story” is based solely on what he heard and was told. These kinds of evidences or depositions are called “Hear to say” and not taken into consideration or credited in the courts of justices.

    It is obvious that the stories in the book are fictious, rather than the reality, actually came into life in the minds of Mr. Arshag Schimavonian, the dragoman (interpreter) of the USA Embassy in Istanbul who acted as the Ambassador Morgenthau’s advisor and right hand together with his secretary Mr. Hagop Andonian who both were anti-Turkish Armenians. Their made up stories ingeniously converted to a novel style history book by Mr. Burton J. Hendrick, a Pulitzer Prize winner, who actually is the ghost writer of the book. He did write the book using all his skills.

    Pulitzer Prize winner Mr. Hendrick, by magically “putting words in their mouths” of the story tellers as if there was a sound recorder and the conversations were put down verbatim years later in the book, made a fortune out of this tell-a-tale book, by receiving forty percent of the revenues from the sales and a mere $15,000 in cash, equivalent of $1,263,823 of the year 2012. Dressings were all produced in the USA to make the story look real either by Hendrick himself or Schimavonian and Andonian.

    The main reason why the book titled “Ambassador Morgenthau’s Story” published was to write a book damning the Turks and the Germans, which would justify the USA’s entrance in the war. It was the idea of Ambassador Morgenthau and he made his offer to President Wilson, whom he was very close to. USA and Britain knew that this was an “Ordered book to serve as a trump card” for USA to participate in WW I.

    President Wilson supported the idea and a new team was set up for his alleged services in Turkey to be explained in his reputed book. The team leaders were Mr. Arshag Schimavonian and Mr. Hagop Andonian. Although the author of the book is declared to be the Ambassador Henry Morgenthau, it is by now known by everybody that the actual writer was Mr. Burton J. Hendrick and he considered Morgenthau’s, Schimavonian’s and Andonian’s stories as reliable sources.

    After almost 75 years the credibility of the Morgenthau’s book was scholarly researched and a serious check back was done by Prof. Heath W. Lowry for the first time in his book “The Story Behind Ambassador Morgenthau’s Story”, published by the Isis Press, Istanbul 1990 (ISBN 975-428-019-3). The result was a disaster for Mr. “Ambassador Morgenthau’s Story” book.

    This very book titled “Preposterous Paradoxes of Ambassador Morgenthau” written solely by Mr. Sükrü Server Aya, the reliable and distinguished researcher on the Armenian Allegations, cross checks day by day the diary of Mr. Ambassador and his notorious book titled “Ambassador Morgenthau’s Story”.

    I used word “notorious” deliberatively, because the output of this cross check reveals the fact that Mr. Ambassador’s book was tailored rather than conveying the real truth on what happened before, during and after deportation on the year 1915.

    Professor Dr. Ata ATUN

    Academic and Researcher
    T.R.N. Cyprus


    The book review is on page:

    https://armenians-1915.blogspot.com/2012/11/3379-book-review-preposterous-paradoxes.html

     

    The book is a continuation of the chapter 15 of Armenians-1915.blogspot.com/2010/12/3189-genocide-of-truth-continues-but.html which can be read and downloaded at the given link

    For more remarks by Aya on Morgenthau see also Armenians-1915.blogspot.com/2010/08/3121-morgenthau-book-review-by-sukru.html

    This last book of about 240 pages, elaborates deeper and demonstrates the distortions and inversions by Ambassador Morgenthau. It compares verbatim excerpts from his book “Ambassador Morgenthau’s Story”, with what he had written on the very same matter in his personal diary kept by him and/or his secretary Hagop Andonian daily, noting the important events. Where necessary, other “neutral documents” are quoted to show that Morgenthau’s Book, is an “excellent book of boasting, diversions and inexplicable lies” he introduced in 1918 by this book (almost four years after the events happened) to create a document damning Turks and Germans, to give “a humane cause” to USA to take part in WW1. Mr. Morgenthau’s Diary written in his hand writing (or his secretary’s) belies the polished words written in his book (by the Pulitzer prize winner ghost writer Burton Hendrick, putting words in mouths as if they were copied from a sound recorder).


    Labels: Book REVIEW, Sukru AYA

    Important Reminder:  See three articles by Mehmet Perincek in Turkish-English giving new information about Morgenthau from Russian archives-link: 
    https://armenians-1915.blogspot.com/2012/11/3378-what-did-talat-pasha-speak-with.html

     

     

  • EU – Enlargement – Aid Programme for the Turkish Cypriot Community – European Commission

    EU – Enlargement – Aid Programme for the Turkish Cypriot Community – European Commission

    Aid Programme for the Turkish Cypriot Community

    Background

    Cyprus joined the EU on 1 May 2004 as a de facto divided island. The EU fully supports the current negotiations (under the auspices of the UN) between the leaders of the Greek Cypriot and Turkish Cypriot communities which aim to reach a comprehensive settlement leading to the re-unification of the island and establish a bi-zonal, bi-communal federation in which the communities would enjoy political equality. Such a settlement is urgently needed to end a conflict that is now more than 40 years old.

    The EU will accommodate a Cyprus settlement that allows the country to play its full role as an EU member while respecting the EU’s basic founding principles – democracy, the rule of law and human rights.

    Pending a settlement, the European Commission has several specific responsibilities with regard to Cyprus, over and above its normal responsibilities toward a member country:

    closely following the negotiation process and providing political and technical support

    directly implementing the aid programme decided by EU member countries to help the Turkish Cypriots prepare for reunification.

    regularly reporting on the implementation of the Green Line Regulation.

    To meet these responsibilities, the Commission’s Directorate-General for Enlargement has set up the Task Force for the Turkish Cypriot community. The task force runs a ProgrammeSupport Office (EUPSO) in the northern part of Nicosia, to act as a contact with the beneficiary community and help deliver the assistance.

    The Green Line

    The whole of Cyprus is EU territory. However, in the northern part of the island, where the Government of Cyprus does not exercise effective control, EU legislation is suspended in line with protocol 10 of the 2003 accession treaty.

    Since 1974 the “Green Line” separates the two parts of the island. The EU’s Green Line Regulation 866/2004 , sets out the terms under which persons and goods can cross this line, which is not an external border of the EU.

    The main practical effect is that the northern areas are outside the EU’s customs and fiscal territory – but this does not affect the personal rights of Turkish Cypriots as EU citizens. They are citizens of an EU country – the Republic of Cyprus – even if they live in a part of Cyprus not under government control.

    The situation will change once a Cyprus settlement enters into force and EU rules apply over the whole of the island.

    While many people move across the green line every day, trade across the line is limited (approximately €400,000 per month).

    Aid for the Turkish Cypriot community

    In 2006, the EU approved aid regulation 389/2006 to end the isolation of the Turkish Cypriot community and to help prepare for reunification. €259 million was allocated for a 5‑year programme to be implemented by the Commission (DG Enlargement).

    Programme objectives:

    promote social and economic development in the Turkish Cypriot community (particularly rural, human‑resources and regional development)

    develop and refurbish infrastructure (particularly energy, transport, environment, telecommunications and water supply)

    foster reconciliation, build confidence and support civil society

    bring the Turkish Cypriot community closer to the EU, through information and contacts between Turkish Cypriots and other EU citizens

    help the Turkish Cypriot community prepare for the implementation of EU law once a comprehensive settlement of the Cyprus issue is agreed.

    From 2011 on, assistance has continued in the form of annual allocations of €28 million, to build on the results achieved and support the ongoing UN process.

    For more information on EU assistance to the Turkish Cypriot community, have a look at our brochure or go to the website of the EU InfoPoint.

    Brochure : ec.europa.eu/enlargement/pdf/key_documents/2012/20121128_assistance_to_tcc_brochure.pdf

    via EU – Enlargement – Aid Programme for the Turkish Cypriot Community – European Commission.

  • ‘Istanbul-Paphos flight listing causes confusion’

    ‘Istanbul-Paphos flight listing causes confusion’

    CONFUSION was caused yesterday when the official Hermes airport website indicated that a direct flight from Istanbul to Paphos operated by Greece’s AZI (Astra airlines) would be landing in Cyprus at 3.40am tomorrow.

    Due to a flight embargo enforced by Ankara there are no direct flights from Turkey to Cyprus

    Hermes airport spokesman Adam Aspris assured the Cyprus Mail the website listing was a technical oversight, which would be corrected immediately.

    He said:” This flight is carrying the AEL football team who are playing in Istanbul. The flight, as is required, made a stop at Diagoras International Airport in Rhodes, before continuing to Cyprus. This is due to the fact that no direct flights are permitted by Turkey.”

    Due to the glitch, the website indicated where flight ZS949 initially originated from, when it should have stated the flight came from Rhodes.

    AEL left for Istanbul yesterday morning to play Fenerbahce in the Europa League.

    via ‘Istanbul-Paphos flight listing causes confusion’ – Cyprus Mail.

  • Cyprus ignores Turkey, says to continue with natgas projects

    Cyprus ignores Turkey, says to continue with natgas projects

    November 05, 2012

    RECORDER REPORT

    Cyprus on Sunday vowed to continue to develop offshore natural gas reserves, accusing arch-rival Turkey of trying to stir tensions after warning multinationals off participating in the island’s projects.

    Sharpened rhetoric between the two neighbours bitterly divided by a war almost 40 years ago underscores tensions in the east Mediterranean over a potential oil and gas bonanza worth billions.

    Cyprus on October 30 said it would start talks with multinationals including Italy’s ENI, South Korea’s Kogas, France’s Total and Russia’s Novatek for the potential development of natural gas fields to the island’s south.

    Turkey maintains ethnically-split Cyprus has no right to explore for oil or gas. On Friday it warned ENI that it would review that firm’s investment in their country if it went ahead with the Cyprus project.

    “Turkey is once again showing its true face,” Cyprus’s foreign ministry said. “It is a record burdened with violations of international law both as regards its international, and national mode of behaviour.”

    via Cyprus ignores Turkey, says to continue with natgas projects | Business Recorder.